The location was great. The Rum House had a fun atmosphere. Excellent Bartender. Rooms were clean and had a nice throwback charm, but felt new.

5 of us went down for complimentary to go breakfast. Which included a fruit, sandwich and drink. Everyone of us took 1 of each. I asked for a coffee and also a small cup of orange juice. The server was very firm and said "NO..1 each". We just paid $600 for 1 night (2 rooms). I was not asking for another breakfast. Just a small cup of orange juice. I felt that was rude and I did not appreciate the inconsideration of such a small request.

Location. Comfortable beds. Beautiful design

The congestion in the lobby area. The wine hour was a good feature but the music/entertainment was too loud for the space. This would have been better if it was more background to enable conversations rather than loud and distorting. The construction noise at night was pretty prominent too- needed ear plugs for good rest

Ideal location, lovely restaurant. The Art Deco decor in the main areas is gorgeous.

Booked a suite, the room was nothing like the photos, much smaller and dated. I complained and we were shown another room much larger and had been fully redecorated BUT there was demolition and hammer drills going on outside the room and scaffolding. Needless to say we stayed with the first room!! There was no other offer to move or help us with our stay.

Times square is practically downstairs and when you feel the need to pee or have a lot of stuff bought..you can always bring it back to the room

Excellent location near Times Square. Decoration and historic hotel, very traditional that remember us from films. Bar with good live music, jazz to blues.

Breakfast is weak, little options to choose from. I've been in many hotels across the world and usually when breakfast is included we have variety, here either you pay complementary money to a full breakfast or you just have one of two burgers, and one piece of fruit or a croissant or yoghurt.

Location was excellent, right off Times Square, and staff was friendly and helpful. Don't pay extra for early check-in, just ask when you get there. We had our bags held while we explored and it was much cheaper.

There was no fridge in the room which would've been nice to keep waters cold or leftovers food fresh. If you're a light sleeper, bring earplugs.

Good value. Room was clean and beds were comfortable. Staff was professional, courteous and helpful. Location was perfect for Broadway. Lunch at Friedman's was quick and delicious. Amazing bonus if you are gluten free. Valet was professional, reasonably priced and so quick and easy to deal with.

Door on 46th St closed. Grab and go breakfast was underwhelming. No food available after 10, not even takeout. Play ended at 9:30 and food stops at 10.

Hotel Edison is in an excellent location for attending theatre, which was the purpose of our visit. The room was very clean and well furnished, but rather small(or as my daughter said “cozy”. ) There were 4 of us, two adults and two teenagers, and it was a bit of a squeeze. The bar and the restaurant were very nice. I would definitely recommend the hotel.

The Hotel location is perfect few steps from time square and broad ways , hotel is safe , room need to be updated ( it look old) , add more lights in the room , no fridge in the room .

Central location and grab and go breakfast was a good service Also luggage storage ( although I don’t think you should have to pay for this )

That they were only going to give us breakfast for only two of us In a family of four ! We booked with bookings.com which clearly stated breakfast included ! No view